McCain contradicts himself

McCain contradicts himself

By Mark Mellman

Posted: 09/09/08 06:02 PM [ET]

John McCain offers America a welter of contradictions in both character and policy — contradictions so profound they call into question the fundamental premises of his campaign. McCain’s brash display of those contradictions suggests at best a total absence of self-awareness and at worst an even more dangerous condition. For example, what does it mean for John McCain to tell us he wants to end the “rancor” in Washington while presiding over a convention now infamous for its rancor? No one watching that convention in full possession of their faculties could have listened to the personal invective heaped upon vituperative attack, layered with scurrilous lies, leaned back and said, “There is a guy who will end the rancor in Washington and extend the hand of cooperation across the aisle.” More fundamental is the contradiction between a man who self-righteously expresses his desire to reform Washington by kicking out lobbyists and limiting special interest influence, but who has been deeply enmeshed in that system from his days as a member of the Keating Five until today, employing the very lobbyists he decries to run his campaign. McCain revels in telling Americans he has “never done any favors for anybody — lobbyist or special interest group,” an assertion as bold as it is absurd. When Charles Keating, a savings and loan magnate who used government-insured accounts to make risky real estate investments that eventually cost taxpayers nearly $3.5 billion, asked McCain to intercede with regulators, introduce legislation to benefit him and secure the nomination of a Keating associate to a regulatory board, McCain readily complied. More recently, the chairman of the Federal Communications Commission publicly rebuked McCain for attempting to interfere with commission decisions on behalf of a lobbyist. McCain backed some $16 billion in tax breaks for big oil companies as they rack up record profits. Was that the national interest speaking to him, or were the million dollars in contributions from oil executives doing the talking? Perhaps most appalling is the contradiction between McCain’s call for change and his embrace of George Bush’s policies on the core issues of Iraq and the economy. Yes, there have been times when McCain visibly clashed with his own party, but on most of those issues — immigration and tax policy, for example — he has publicly recanted, begging to be readmitted to the band of loyal followers. For McCain to suggest he is an agent of change on Iraq policy is positively Orwellian. An early cheerleader for Bush’s war who has never, for even a second, entertained the possibility that it was a mistake, McCain wants to keep sending our soldiers and spending our tax dollars there, indefinitely. Of course, he wants the situation on the ground to improve (so does George Bush), but John McCain supports a long-term, even permanent, U.S. military presence in Iraq. That is not change. Throughout Bush’s second term, McCain has also steadfastly supported every single plank of Bush’s economic policy. Tax breaks for Big Oil and the wealthiest individuals — he is for them. An increase in the minimum wage — he is against it. Healthcare? McCain put forward George Bush’s healthcare plan as his own — a plan that would end the tax deduction for employer-paid health insurance, leaving millions uninsured with a $5,000 tax credit to pay for a $12,000 insurance policy. McCain lauds Sarah Palin for “taking on oil companies.” What did she do? Palin instituted a windfall profits tax, distributing the proceeds to taxpayers. But McCain explicitly rejects the very economic policy for which he lionizes Palin. McCain’s contradictions would tear a lesser man apart, but should give the rest of us great pause. Mellman is president of The Mellman Group and has worked for Democratic candidates and causes since 1982, including Sen. John Kerry (D-Mass.) in 2004.

Stephen Colbert - On The Republican National Convention and Sarah Palin

What Conservatives Ignored

ELECTION '08

What Conservatives Ignored

With Sen. John McCain's (R-AZ) pick of Gov. Sarah Palin (R-AK) as his vice presidential running mate, excitement and anticipation were running high for the Republican National Convention, which wrapped up yesterday. Hurricane Gustav stormed into the Gulf Coast, however, disrupting the GOP's plans. The McCain campaign tried to act aggressively and decisively, sending McCain and Palin to Missisippi for a hurricane briefing. All of this action was supposed to show that the policies in a McCain administration would be different than those of the Bush administration. But what was most evident during the convention was how similar the two men's policies were. Superficially, convention organizers tried to put distance between the two men. According to an analysis by The Progress Report, Bush's name was mentioned just once during the entire convention; Cheney was never mentioned. But substantively, no new ideas or solutions for the country's current problems were put forth. Even on national security, which was a prominent topic, conservatives refused to engage in any introspection. They referenced Guantanamo Bay once, Osama bin Laden once, and never uttered Afghanistan or the name of former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld.

THE ECONOMY: The American public views the struggling economy as the most important issue facing the country. But as AFP observed, "The economy may be the number one issue in the White House race, but the Republican National Convention has yet to dwell on the troubles of Americans trying to make ends meet." On Wednesday, CNBC said its reporters were "darned to find much at all" about the economy in the convention speeches. In fact, housing was mentioned just once and the term "middle-class" was used only twice. Rep. Adam Putnam (R-FL) claimed that Palin explained McCain's "economic message" in her address, but when CNBC asked him "in your words, what is that economic message," Putnam couldn't put forward any specifics. McCain did mention the economy several times in his acceptance speech last night, declaring, "I know some of you have been left behind in the changing economy and it often seems your government hasn't even noticed. ... That's going to change on my watch." However, his prescriptions would continue Bushonomics. McCain has repeatedly expressed pride in Bush's failed economic policies. In April, he told Bloomberg TV, "You could make an argument that there's been great progress economically" during the Bush administration. During a January primary debate, McCain claimed that Americans "overall are better off" than they were eight years ago.

HEALTH CARE: At a town hall event last month, McCain declared, "There is a health care crisis in America. We would be, if it were not for the energy crisis, we'd be talking a lot more about health care issues." But despite skyrocketing health care costs and millions of uninsured and underinsured Americans, nearly every prominent speaker at the Republican National Convention ignored this crisis. Gov. Sarah Palin (R-AK), Gov. Mike Huckabee (R-AR), Mayor Rudy Giuliani (R-NY), and Sen. Fred Thompson (R-TN) never addressed health care. Gov. Mitt Romney (R-MA) only discussed "health insurance" in passing. On Tuesday, Huckabee, a long-time advocate of wellness and fitness, "said his health care remarks were cut for time restrictions." McCain devoted just one sentence to the topic, giving no specifics: "My health care plan will make it easier for more Americans to find and keep good health care insurance." But McCain believes that Americans would be better off finding health care on their own, in the private market. As Center for American Progress Action Fund Senior Fellow Elizabeth Edwards has noted, this system would bar more Americans from receiving coverage. "A recent study showed that nearly nine out of every ten people seeking individual coverage on the private insurance market never got it," wrote Edwards. "People who have had cancer are denied coverage and those who get cancer run the risk of simply being dropped by their insurer for any excuse that can be found."

GLOBAL WARMING: Hurricane Gustav threatened to overtake coverage of the GOP convention. Recognizing the potential destruction and severity of the crisis, the McCain campaign made sure to address the crisis by changing the theme of the first day to "service." However, after that first day, the hurricane was rarely mentioned again. Republicans never said "Katrina" and the word "hurricane" was actually used only seven times in convention speeches. Republicans also ignored the obvious link between global warming and the increasing intensity of storms: the terms "global warming" and "climate change" were each mentioned just once. A new study published in the journal Nature this week found that "the strongest of hurricanes and typhoons have become even stronger over the past two and a half decades." James Elsner, a professor of geography at Florida State University and lead author of the paper, said that the findings indicated "a climate signal." Despite McCain's claims that he believes global warming is real, the GOP platform -- which McCain has promised to run on -- is loaded with caveats about the uncertainty of science and the need to 'resist no-growth radicalism' in taking on climate change." Palin has said she doesn't believe that global warming is man-made, a position with which the majority of the American public disagrees.

ADMINISTRATION -- WOODWARD BOOK SAYS BUSH SPIED ON IRAQI PRIME MINISTER: According to a new book by investigative journalist Bob Woodward, "The Bush administration has conducted an extensive spying operation on [Iraqi] Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki, his staff and others in the Iraqi government." "We know everything he says," explained one of the sources in "The War Within: A Secret White House History, 2006-2008," which is scheduled to be released on Monday. In the book, Woodward also "portrays an administration riven by dissension, either unwilling or slow to confront the deterioration of its strategy in Iraq during the summer and early fall of 2006." He reports on the "discord" between Bush and Gen. George Casey, then-commander of forces in Iraq, and says that in October 2006, "Bush asked his national security adviser, Stephen Hadley, to carry out a review of the Iraq war," which "was kept secret for fear of jeopardising the Republican party's popularity in the mid-term congressional elections." Woodward also claims that "groundbreaking surveillance techniques -- and not the much-trumpeted surge by 30,000 additional troops -- were the main reason for the reduction in violence in Iraq during the past 16 months." MILITARY -- SOLDIER SUICIDE RATE MAY SET RECORD AGAIN: Yesterday, Army officials said that soldiers suicides this year "could surpass the record rate of last year." There were 62 confirmed suicides among active duty soldiers and Guard and Reserve troops as of the end of last month, with another 31 suspected to be suicides but still under investigation. If those 31 are confirmed, "the number for 2008 could eclipse the 115 last year -- and the rate per 100,000 could surpass that of the civilian population." In April, CBS News reported that the Department of Veterans Affairs deliberately withheld information about the suicide risk among veterans. One internal department e-mail about the subject began with, "Shh!" and wondered how to control the alarming statistics "before someone stumbles on it." Days after attacking CBS for supposedly inflating the numbers of veteran suicides, the VA's head of Mental Health sent an internal e-mail admitting the rate of suicides "is supported by CBS numbers." A recent survey found that "about 12% of combat troops in Iraq and 17% of those in Afghanistan are taking prescription antidepressants or sleeping pills to help them cope." RADICAL RIGHT -- GINGRICH CLAIMS U.S. HAS MORE OIL AND GAS SUPPLIES THAN VENEZUELA OR SAUDI ARABIA: During an appearance on the Tavis Smiley show earlier this week, former House speaker Newt Gingrich -- stumping for his "Drill Here, Drill Now, Pay Less" campaign funded by right-wing billionaires to sell the Big Oil agenda -- claimed that "if you used America's energy resources and you didn't have to buy oil from Venezuela or Saudi Arabia it'd be a lot less expensive." Yet what Gingrich didn't mention is that the United States has only 2 percent of the world's oil and gas reserves but uses 24 percent of production. This isn't the first time Gingrich has showed his ignorance on energy issues. He has previously said that inflating car tires properly in order to save energy is "loony tunes" even though both the Department of Energy and the auto industry advocate such practices. A few days later he made the astonishing claim that inflating your tires somehow enriches Big Oil's profits.

The U.S. unemployment rate rose to a five-year high of 6.1 percent in August, "heightening the risk that the economic slowdown will worsen." "Payrolls fell by 84,000 in August, and revisions added another 58,000 to job losses for the prior two months," while "the number of U.S. workers filing new claims for jobless benefits jumped by 15,000 last week."

Pentagon leaders have "recommended to President Bush that the United States make no further troop reductions in Iraq this year." The plan "calls for extending a pause in drawdowns until late January or early February" when up to 7,500 troops will be redeployed to Afghanistan.

In August, high energy and food prices led consumers to shop at retail stores in high numbers, "leaving department stores and other sectors struggling." "Demand for necessities helped chains such as retail giant Wal-Mart Stores Inc. perform above expectations."

Rep. Charles B. Rangel (D-NY) "has earned more than $75,000 in rental income from a villa he has owned in the Dominican Republic since 1988, but never reported it on his federal or state tax returns." Rangel will "most likely file amendments to his tax returns for the years in question," pay back taxes in New York City and state but "will probably have no federal tax liability."

"Aid to poor nations has slumped even as higher food and energy prices and slowing global economic growth have made such assistance more urgent," the UN reported. Aid dropped 8.4 percent last year, and though the Group of 8 nations in 2005 pledged $25 billion to Africa by 2010, "just $4 billion has actually been delivered."

And finally: MSNBC's Andrea Mitchell was almost buried by balloons on the floor of the RNC last night. Host Keith Olbermann advised her to "flee," and ended her segment saying she had been "reporting from the political equivalent of a Chuck E. Cheese, apparently."

Five Star Shitstorm - The Republican National Convention

Wait until you get to the part in the video from last night's Daily Show where they interview a "typical Republican delegate" on Monday night while Hurricane Gustav was rolling into Louisiana, really, truly pissed off that the RNC canceled Monday's events "because a few people are gettin' rained on". It's unbelievable to me that people like that actually exist in the world or that they have found a home in the Republican Party. In looking throughout the hall where the RNC is being held, I must admit I have never seen so many white people in one place since, well, the last Republican National Convention. This is a party for white people only? Or the occasional token minority? In this country? Right now? I can't believe it. I hope Sarah Palin-Von Schtupp wows 'em tonight on the benefits of being a woman from a state where men outnumber women 20:1. All those white folks need to learn how to dance, on the floor and in bed.

Randy Shiner